Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Memo Post IV: Primary Sources


I loved my interview responses.  I decided to stick with only students for my primary interviewees, as their words are recorded less in academic settings.  I went into the interviews with my own idea about how they may respond, and they were not anywhere near correct. I interviewed students from all different grade levels and a lot of their feedback was profound. While I asked questions directed at what type of writing they do in school or why they’re asked to write, they’re answers were much more personal. Even though some of them didn’t enjoy writing, they all felt it would be valuable to them after school, for example, in getting jobs. But what I really appreciated were there answers that writing helped them express what their opinions were, or enter the dialogue of content, or to make sense of the world around them. So even in school, it seems we are getting the message across that writing is important for bigger reasons then just the grade, or the resume.  They taught me that they understand writing helps them know themselves, the worlds and how they fit into it.

It’s interesting that mostly what I see observed in classrooms are persuasive essays for portfolio, learning to write a narrative and what the elements of a story are, ore evidence sandwich responses to literature: this is my thesis, here is the textual evidence. Or we teach forms of poetry and Shakespeare’s sonnets, yet we are getting larger ideas across.

This leads me to more questions for research, or practice. Specifically, how do we get this larger idea across? How do we give students the assignments and space to understand the world and themselves through their writing? It impresses upon me the need to give students a large variety so that they can have the option to add their voice where and how they choose. It also means writing-to-learn is essential and a practice we should utilize more often.  Rather than only graded, final products how can we emphasize those more informal, personal writings our students do as they’re still struggling with ideas or questions?

No comments:

Post a Comment