Tuesday, February 24, 2015

Memo II: Taking Off from our Inital Research


For my initial research I found two books and an article linked to the RIC library website as well as reviewed the Common Core standards for high school writing.

The first book I read was called Burn this Book, and is a collection of essays from well-known authors answering the question why do they write. One thing I noticed in this book is that many of the answers were to the question why write fiction and so the question already seemed narrowed down. Additionally many of the answers had strong biases towards why writing is important because it was asked to a group of people who already enjoy and excel at writing. There are some important ideas however in their answers. For example Toni Morrison mentioned that for centuries writers have been persecuted by controlling governments which in itself proves the power of writers. John Updike mentions the creation of empathy that writing affords us by allowing us new perspectives and also the idea of writing as a catharsis for the individual. And Francine Prose concludes her answer by reminding us that writing is a way to grope with and discover new things. So this leads me to think about the idea that perhaps writing as a process is the important part rather than what writing we are teaching.

However, I then read the article “Read Long and Prosper: The Five Do’s and Don’ts to Prepare Students for College.” This article was written from a college professor’s perspective about what he would like to see happening in high school classrooms. Most of his view was obviously how to teach with the goal of getting students to college. With this in mind most of his tips were for research and analytical writing skills. One tip was that students should do more long writing pieces which must be broken down into smaller tasks. Addionatlly that they should do more individual writing and that they should be taught more effective ways to find sources for good research papers. His emphasis in this last tip was to avoid using technology too much and teach students to find more traditional sources. Most of his ideas were that if writing is geared towards success in college then emphasis needs to be on how to write extended research works and apply sources correctly.

Next I read the book Writing as a Political Act. This book was not as helpful as the other sources. Its focus was on “basic” writers and the discourse on this population and “basic” writing. I’m not positive what this actually means in this context but from what I read I believe their using the term basic to mean remedial. So again this was a source with too specific of an audience. It addressed specifically those who perhaps do not excel at writing in school and how it’s handled. One thing this source did contribute to my research is a new string of questions such as: Do our reasons for teaching writing change based on skill level? If so, how? And is this ok to have different expectations?  If not, should it? The authors also mentioned that in doing their research for the book they found that “ students perceive a vast difference between what they imagine to be ‘writing’ and what they are doing in classes and learning in school” (Kassner and Harrington 34). So this reinforced some of my initial questions for the project: What do students think is the reason we write? Are teachers and students on the same page? And also how do we get on the same page?

The last source I looked at are the Common Core Standards for writing in grades 9-12. I had already had an introduction to writers’ ideas, professors’ ideas and even a bit of student input, now I wanted a basic understanding of the national level. I focused mostly on the text types and purposes specified in the standards. They echoed some similar principles to why the writers write. There was one for informational texts, students should learn to write informational pieces with substantive, effective sources and evidenced for their argument. They should also write explanatory texts in which they are engaging with ideas and learning to organize thoughts most effectively and analyze content to make some sense out of it in order to pass that new understanding on. The third type of text is narrative with an emphasis on effective detail and proper sequencing of events. The standards didn’t answer concretely why we think these skills are important and relevant as a nation. But if this is what we think is important there must also be an extension of why we think these are the most crucial.

No comments:

Post a Comment